I made an Easy Vegan Pecan Pie for our Christmas dessert, and it was a big hit with our guests and us. The recipe, from the cleverly named website It Doesn’t Taste Like Chicken, was perfect: pecans, bourbon, vanilla, a hint of cinnamon, and loads of sugar, including brown sugar.
I deviated from the recipe only to use agave in place of the corn syrup (a substitution endorsed by the recipe’s creator, Sam Turnbull) and arrowroot in place of the corn starch, so I could avoid consuming products of the corn industrial complex.
For New Year’s, I made a Cranberry Chiffon Pie. It was somewhat disappointing but not at all bad.
My main gripe was that I could taste the pomegranate juice used in the recipe almost as much as the fresh cranberries, with the result that the pie tasted more like a Cranberry-Pomegranate Chiffon Pie to me. Maybe the recipe creator tried cranberry juice, but the result was too tart?
I had planned to buy or make some vegan whipped cream to decorate the top, but the vegan whipping creams I found contained either oats or fava beans, neither of which would be good for Tony.
I decided not to make the decorative Sugared Cranberries because I didn’t feel like buying sanding sugar for this one recipe. As it turned out, I needed to make an extra run to Sprouts to buy more cranberries because I burned the cranberry-pomegranate jam the first time I attempted it because I was trying to get ahead on other steps in the process at the same time and wasn’t paying enough attention to my jam.
I once again, for both pies, used a Wholly Wholesome gluten-free and dairy-free crust. Someday, I’ll try making my own GF and DF pie crust, but Tony and I are both pleased with this store-bought kind. And making the filling was a good deal of work in and of itself: First, you make that jam—the recipe actually calls it a “loose jam”—out of the cranberries, pomegranate juice, and sugar. Then you dissolve gelatin in water and cook egg yolks combined with milk (I used cashew milk), salt, and more sugar. Then you add the gelatin to the egg yolk mixture and then that combined mixture to the cranberry-pomegranate jam.
The most time-consuming part was making meringue, which I chose to do by hand for some reason. I’m pretty certain my meringue got to the called-for stiff peaks stage.
Finally, you add the meringue to the cranberry–egg yolk–gelatin mixture, put the completed filling in the prebaked pie shell, and chill the pie until the filling is set.
I made the pie on Dec. 29, the Sunday before New Year’s, because I had plenty of time that day and didn’t know whether I would the next two days. We polished it off on New Year’s Eve.
On New Year’s Day, I made my second attempt at Eggnog Vegan Frozen Dessert. I was pleased with the final result but dissatisfied with the texture of the base after it was cooked and after it was chilled, so it’s still not ready for my cookbook.
This time, I tried incorporating two vegan eggs (instead of just one) into the custard base, and I tried cooking the base for longer—10 minutes—to try to improve the level of incorporation. The longer cooking time didn’t seem to make much difference; there was an awful lot of leftover vegan egg when I strained the base.
There were also little clumps of offputting, slimy egginess in the base after it was made and after it was chilled, and this base didn’t take on a pudding-like texture in the fridge like my bases always do when I let them chill overnight.
However, after I processed the base in my ice cream maker and froze the finished VFD solid, the texture was good. The VFD had little specks of egg throughout, but they didn’t bother me any.
The taste was perfect—a melding of bourbon (1 tablespoon), vanilla (2 teaspoons), and freshly grated nutmeg (1 heaping teaspoon). I used bourbon instead of rum this time because I already had a small bottle on hand that I’d bought for the Easy Vegan Pecan Pie.
My next attempt, which I may or may not blog about, will probably utilize only one vegan egg, and I will cook the custard for more than 10 minutes, hoping the smaller amount of vegan egg and longer cooking time will finally do the trick. I’m looking for a better texture at the in between stages of the VFD base, because I don’t think people will trust the recipe when they start to see unpleasant eggy blobs in their base.